The Clue
On April 12, 2023, the New York Times presented a mini crossword puzzle featuring the clue: “Philly N.B.A. player, informally,” with the answer comprising six letters and beginning with an S. If you guessed “SIXER,” you hit the mark. This term serves as informal shorthand for a player affiliated with the Philadelphia 76ers, the NBA franchise hailing from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. While the clue appeared straightforward, it ignited a lively debate across social media platforms among basketball aficionados and crossword enthusiasts alike.
The Debate
Some individuals contended that the clue was excessively straightforward and evident, particularly for a Tuesday puzzle. They argued that individuals versed in basketball would swiftly identify the answer without any difficulty, asserting that the clue failed to test the solver’s depth of knowledge or skill.
Conversely, others disagreed, deeming the clue too obscure and unjust, particularly for solvers outside the United States. They posited that not everyone is acquainted with the nicknames of NBA teams or players, highlighting that the clue relied on cultural and geographical presumptions that marginalized many potential solvers.
The discussion also prompted inquiries regarding the overarching purpose of crosswords. Are they primarily educational or entertaining? Should they reflect the diversity of their audience or cater to a specific demographic? How do they strike a balance between accessibility and challenge?
The Perspective
According to Will Shortz, the crossword editor of the New York Times, the clue was not meant to ignite controversy or division. He stated that he endeavors to create puzzles that appeal to a broad spectrum of solvers, while also considering the puzzle’s difficulty level and theme.
Shortz clarified that the mini crossword is designed to be simple and speedy, often featuring clues related to current events or popular culture. He chose the clue “Philly N.B.A. player” because it was timely, given the 76ers’ strong performance in the league this season.
He further explained that he didn’t perceive the clue as overly obscure or unfair, presuming that most solvers would possess at least some familiarity with NBA teams or players. While striving to avoid overly specific or regional clues, he also aims to steer clear of those that are too generic or mundane.
Shortz emphasized his receptiveness to solver feedback and his ongoing commitment to honing his craft. He expressed hope that the puzzles provide enjoyment for all, regardless of their background or preferences.
The Conclusion
The clue “Philly N.B.A. player” appears deceptively simple, yet it unveils the intricate tapestry of crosswords and their solvers. It underscores that crosswords transcend mere wordplay; they embody culture, knowledge, and perspective.
Moreover, it demonstrates that crosswords serve as a forum for dialogue, discourse, and enlightenment. They challenge our preconceptions, expand our understanding, and stimulate our intellect. Additionally, they foster unity as we exchange insights, viewpoints, and experiences.
Hence, when faced with a crossword clue that perplexes or stirs you, don’t despair or react defensively. Instead, embrace curiosity and open-mindedness. You may uncover novel insights or perceive things from a fresh angle. And amidst it all, you might just have a bit of fun.